I voted Picard because he is my favorite Captain, And Actor.
http://www.cnn.com/HLN/There's a poll here asking, who would you serve under in Star Trek. Being unsure, I voted for Janeway. I found it kinda hard to pick between Picard, Sisko, and Janeway. After voting, I seen she needed the vote more then Picard or Sisko.
I voted Janeway, because she is my favorite captain in that she blends in with the crew, unlike Picard who is rather anti-social. If nothing else, she's cool cuz she's gone on over 1/2 of the away missions Voyager had.
I voted Picard because I wanted someonewho wasn't afraid to order his crew on dangerous missions.